At no other point in recent history has psychological safety been more important – not only in the workplace, but in every area of society due to the pandemic. Such an environment requires leaders across sectors to reconsider the rules and tools they apply when managing teams. As they work on strategies to successfully move business forward, they must also address the elevated concerns employees now have around physical safety, job security, mental health, family life and isolation. All of these pressing issues make the important work of Harvard Business School Professor Amy Edmondson even more timely and relevant.
Edmondson, a renowned expert on organizational learning and leadership and the #1 ranked management thinker in the world by Thinkers50, has been studying psychological safety and workplace behaviors for more than 20 years. During that time, her work has helped major firms vastly improve performance by building an environment of psychological safety, transparency and collaborative teaming, which ultimately leads to more effective operations, more engaged employees and a healthier bottom line. She shares a handful of representative case studies in her 2018 bestselling book, “The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation and Growth.”
As the Novartis Professor of Leadership and Management at Harvard Business School – a chair established to support the study of human interactions that lead to the creation of successful enterprises – Edmondson helps organizations identify barriers to success that are often hidden inside a workplace culture by ensuring people feel safe to speak up about problems they see and to offer suggestions for doing things better, without fear of reprisal.
“Absent data on what’s not working, it’s all but impossible to know what to fix and how to fix it. No data, no progress,” wrote Edmondson in a March 2020 Harvard Business Review article. “It takes courage to choose transparency — and wisdom to know that the choice is the right one for achieving the goals that matter to all.”
Amidst the rapidly evolving business landscape, the path to growth often lies in places least expected. In her highly anticipated new book, “Right Kind of Wrong: The Science of Failing Well“ (Atria Books, September 2023), which won the Financial Times and Schroders Business Book of the Year 2023, Edmondson proposes a refreshing perspective, where certain kinds of failures aren’t viewed as setbacks but as invaluable learning opportunities. These “intelligent failures,” as she dubs them, are the vital stepping stones that lead to innovation and discovery. Diving deep into the distinction between intelligent, basic and complex failures, she explains the proactive steps that can prevent harmful failures in the future. Kind and empathetic, she demonstrates to organizations how they can shift their mindsets and behaviors to support competitive advantage and success in an uncertain environment.
Over the years, Edmondson and her colleagues have conducted numerous studies showing the progress made at companies where problems were brought to light and highlighting the catastrophes that ensued when they were not. The results further confirmed that organizations that foster speaking up are more effective in dealing with challenges of every kind.
While any organization can be classified as a complex, error-prone system, Edmondson sees hospitals as particularly revealing case studies in that the stakes are high and the processes are complex. One of her cases involved a hospital setting rife with finger-pointing and blame that made it extremely difficult for anyone to speak up about mistakes and problems. Edmondson documents how a new COO worked to shift the culture by reframing the language around problems, changing words like “error” to “accident” and “investigation” to “study.” This moved failure analyses from an exercise in “who did it?” to a neutral “what happened?” which, in turn, gave employees a comfort level with reporting problems and superiors the information they needed to address issues and make changes.
“When the bad news starts pouring in — whether reporting crimes in a city, medical errors in a hospital, or new patient cases in a pandemic — this actually means you’ve jumped over your first hurdle to success,” says Edmondson. “With accurate information, people can turn their attention and skills to the challenges of developing novel solutions to the newly visible problems. Rather than living with false confidence that all is well, leaders and subject matter experts alike can instead get to work on what needs to be done.”
And for those company leaders who believe everything is fine, Edmondson warns that may not be good enough, and certainly won’t be five years from now.
“You can be part of a great organization that is still vulnerable,” says Edmondson. “Leaders must assume around every corner is a potential problem or a chance to do something better. The idea is to flip thinking from ‘we don’t have a problem,’ to ‘how can we improve?’”